BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
Mar
11
Written by:
3/11/2011 11:33 AM
In coming days, Australian investors in BHP (
BHP-ASX) will be receiving paperwork detailing the company's recently announced, off-market share buy back. With so many 'Mum and Dad' investors holding BHP, and the technical nature of the buy back being a little difficult to understand, I thought it might be helpful to outline the details as simply as possible for anyone struggling to get their head around it and make their decision a little easier.
In short, investors can opt to sell their shares (or a portion of them) back to BHP. The offer will be at a discount to the trading price of shares on the market, which begs the question, why would you sell? Quite simply, it is in the make up of the payment that you find the answer. A very small proportion of the payment will be considered 'capital', and the rest considered a fully franked dividend. If you are a low or no tax paying individual, or the shares are held in a Self Managed Super Fund (SMSF), the tax benefits of accepting the share buy back can be significant. Those of us paying a significant tax rate (30-46.5%) will find the buy back far less attractive.
The first benefit comes in the way of fully franked dividends. It is times like these that you really thank the Australian government for bringing in the imputation credits system to the investment landscape. Once the payment is 'franked up', that is, adjusted for the real return when considering the franking credits applicable, the actual payment received should exceed the on-market share price. This alone makes the share buy back a pretty attractive option for anyone paying minimal or no tax at all. If you still want to hold BHP shares, there is nothing stopping you buying straight back in after accepting the buy back. It's a simple play and could result in some of the easiest returns you ever likely to come by.
The second significant benefit lies in the fact that very little of the payment is considered 'capital'. This in simple terms means you are accepting a tiny amount of money for you 'share', but are taking a large amount as profit in the way of a whopping big dividend. This results in a large capital loss (despite the likely hood that the real return is likely to exceed the market price), and can be used as a capital gain offset should you be selling other shares at a profit. The tax benefit is harder to estimate in this case, but is absolutely a big benefit to those who accept the share buy back.
Consider the following example (this is not the actualy make up of the buy back prices, but simply an indication of how the above principles work). Assume the share price on-market is $45 per share, and the discount offered in the buy back is 14%, resulting in a payment of $38.70 per share in the buy back. Lets say the capital component is only 38c and the fully franked dividend component is $38.32. For a SMSF in pension phase and paying no tax, or a non-tax paying individual, the following would be the real returns (lets also assume the shares were originally purchased at $30 per share).
The capital component offers the shareholder a capital loss of $29.62 per share.
The dividend component offers a return of $38.32 + $16.42 (franking credits) = $54.74
The real return to a non-tax paying individual or SMSF would be $55.12 + a capital loss of $29.62 which can be used in the future to offset a capital gain should it be required.
Considering the above, the shareholder is receiving a premium of over 22% to the on-market price of their BHP shares, along with a handy capital loss which could be used in the future should it be required. Not a bad return in anybody's book. Returns are slightly lower, but still significant for those paying a 15% tax rate (low income earners and SMSF in accumulation phase). Anybody in a low or no taxation position should be considering the share buy back very carefully. For those of us who are not, you can still accept the buy back, but given the maths applied, I can't see much value in doing so.
I hope this will prove helpful to some. I must stress that the above should not be considered advice. Anyone considering participating in the share buy back (or not for that matter) should definitely be seeking advice from a professional advisor on the matter before making any investment decision.
Please Note: For the above calculations regarding the potential capital loss event, I have used the simple calculation using the 38c capital buy back. It is important to note that in most cases, the ATO will make a ruling and attribute a tax value for calculation of the capital loss. This figure used to calculate the capital return is likely to be much higher, however a large capital loss is still almost a certainty. Keep an eye out for a tax ruling or speak to your advisor regarding what the accurate calculation of capital losses will be.
14 comment(s) so far...
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
very help full l rang bhp 3 times with no help at all on the issue of tax, used their calculator and saw l was worse off then selling at market price, as l am on 38.5% tax rate, but after reading your article l am conviced l will not be suck into their buy back scheme
By peter on
3/15/2011 2:26 PM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
Glad I could be of some help Peter.
I must stress that the above is not financial advice and I really do recommend seeking the advice from a professional advisor before making any decision.
All the best with your investment Peter.
By David Press on
3/15/2011 4:56 PM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
Your example refers to a SMSF in pension phase and implies and additional benefit of a carried forward capital loss. If the fund is in pension phase, I thought all capital losses for the year were disregarded?
By Jim on
3/16/2011 11:09 AM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
Sorry Jim, It should have read "for non tax Paying individuals and SMSF in pension phase". The next paragraph does state non tax paying individuals, I've editted the previous paragraph accordingly. Thank you for pointing that out.
I am not an accountant and the above should not be considered advice.
By David Press on
3/16/2011 12:35 PM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
Having had a number of requests regarding how to calculate franking credits and total returns from dividends, I have published a new blog on the matter. Check it out for more info...
www.yourwealthwatch.com.au/Blog/tabid/79/EntryId/31/How-to-Calculate-Gross-Returns-From-Dividend-Payments.aspx
By David Press on
3/20/2011 6:41 PM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
In regards to low income/non tax paying individuals, will the dividend component still form part of personal taxable income? For example, if I sell 2000 shares through this buyback and make $76k in dividends, and that is my only income for the year, is this 'dividend' treated like personal tax income on which I'd have to pay the standard rates of tax?
If so, then it would only make sense to sell only a few shares into the buyback otherwise I'd be up for a massive tax bill of $16,650 minus franking credits of $32571. So I'd get $15921 back as a tax refund.
Can someone confirm that dividends make up part of your taxable income?
By Rodney on
4/1/2011 8:34 PM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
Hi Rodney. Thanks for the comment/question.Firstly I need to make it clear that the blog and following comments are not advice and should definately not be considered as such. A licensed professional advisor/tax accountant should be consulted in this situation.
Dividends are considered income for tax purposes, and as such the normal rates of income tax apply. You would need to calculate how many shares should be sold to maximise the benefits as you have alluded to. I strongly recommend seeking the advice of an accountant in your case.
Here is a link from the ATO regarding investment income and dividends.
ato.gov.au/individuals/content.asp?doc=/content/00227664.htm&page=12#P245_11511
Hope this helps.
By David Press on
4/1/2011 9:09 PM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
Thnk you for your very helpful and prompt advice.
Geoffrey H.
By Geoffrey Harrison on
4/6/2011 8:22 AM
|
air jordan fusion 8,cheap air jordans,discount air jordan
The following Cheap Air Jordans articles within the mouse some why Jordan Retro 11 leather shoes is very popular. Of course Air Jordans not such reason. "The only, so a lot of people like to wear Cheap Jordans, Cheap Jordan Shoes sell Cheap Air Jordans and popularity so positive reproduced, another reason. Here are some more Nike Air Jordan,Air Jordans 8 For Sale.Even many enterprises have to Nike Air Yeezy why people exclaim Air Yeezy Shoes, and not to buy the house for the Air Yeezy.Dr Dre Headphones said: "it is advisable. However, Retro Jordans not only be inconvenient, as long as you a pair of his spirit alone busy, you didn't predict long-term sustained. This is Air Yeezy 2 can do. Cheap Jordans they'll let you of the line of sight of Cheap Chanel Handbags the mount kumgang most likely you always Air Jordans 13 For Sale which type of participation in sport". Cheap Beats By Dr Dre is specific sports activities, and still can Jordan Concords, both capital city, double Monster Beats and jewellery and other fashion items.Manufacturer has also proposed Cheap Jordans, enterprise Banks from Cheap Jordans everyone who believe that children are all jumping and the time required for Chanel J12 Watch, who will support their feet middle-aged fashionable and old man, Jordan Shoes remains to be seen. Everything is Cheap Chanel Bags like compared to comfort good Monster Beats Solo deloitte are activities to wear away, you will continue their Chanel 2.55 Bags treasures collectors for you.In the same group of Beats Headphones is the best qualified design and collect and and movement Monster Beats, and the combination of Monster Beats Pro suit, forever. Do you like Monster Beats Studio, selling shoes Jordan is expected to ease Monster Beats Headphones.
By Retro Air Jordan on
3/12/2012 11:36 AM
|
<a href="http://www.monstersupermanbeats.com/"><strong>Cheap Monster Beats</strong></a> easy to get the perfect fit to seal-in the headphone's sound. Thank you for visiting <A href="http://www.monsterspidermanbea
Cheap Monster Beats easy to get the perfect fit to seal-in the headphone's sound.
Thank you for visiting Cheap Monster Beats For Sale & Beats By Dre Australia Online Stroe .Choose Quality Hot Sale Headphones With 50% off! There isnt Only Wonderful But Aslo Monster Spiderman Beats On Australia Store.Cheap Dre Beats Solo Outlet Buy Authorized Beats By Dre Australia Headphones Online shop.We Offer Excellent Monster Beats By Dr Dre Headphones. You may enjoy Free delivery beats by dre beats is recognized as an innovator in specialty sun retailing with almost 2000 beats by dre beats locations around the world. Situated in a wide variety of Buy Ray Bans Online Now!dr dre australia beats.
By Cheap Monster Beats on
3/20/2012 6:12 PM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
In Europe poker sites that are licensed inside the EU are able to offer their citizens tax-free poker winnings; how do you think rules in the US regarding poker winnings will be once poker is legalized?
By tax-free poker on
4/5/2012 4:14 AM
|
http://www.nikejordanairmaxshoes.com/
Nike Air Max Shoes Air Max ShoesNike Air Maxnike jordan air maxnike air jordonBarefoot Nike Free RunBarefoot Nike Free Run+ 2Barefoot Nike Free Run+ 3Barefoot Nike Free RunBarefoot Free Run 3.0 V2Barefoot Free Run 3.0 V3Barefoot Nike Free 5.0 V4Barefoot Nike Free 7.0Barefoot Nike Free Tr FitDual Fusion St 2Air MaxNike Air Max 2009Nike Air Max 2011Nike Air Max 2012Nike Air Max 24-7Nike Air Max 87Nike Air Max 89Nike Air Max 90Nike Air Max 91Nike Air Max 93Nike Air Max 95Nike Air Max 180Nike Air Max 360Nike Air Max 2010Nike Max Alpha 2012Nike Air Max ACGAir Max Tailwind +4Air Max Classic BWAir Max GriffeyAir Max LTDAir Max SkylineAir Max Terra NinetyNike Air Max TnAir Max ZenythAir Max 2009 HeelsNike Air Max BarkleyNike Lunar Nike LunarGlide+ 3Nike LunarGlide +2Nike LunarGlide +Nike LunarElite+LunarEclipse+ 2Nike LunarEclipse+Nike LunarMX+Nike LunarSwiftNike LunarHazeNike LunarFly+ 2Nike Lunaracer+ 2Lunar Orbit NdLunar Rejven8 MidNike LunarElite+ 2Air JordanAir Jordan 2012Air Jordan 2011Jordan Melo M7Jordan Fly Wade IIJordan Alpha TrunmerJordan HeelsAir Jordan III(3)Air Jordan V(5)Air Jordan IV(4)Jordan Retro XI(11)Jordan 3.5 SpizikerNike Shox Nike Shox R4Nike Shox NZNike Shox TurboAir Force 1Air Force 1 Heels Hi-TopNike Dunk SBNike Dunk Heels Lo-TopNike Dunk Heels Hi-TopNike Dunk Block HeelsNike Dunk Block Heels Hi-TopNike ZoomHyperdunk 2011 LowZoom Kobe VIZoom RookieLebron VIIII 9Zoom Kobe VIIAir GO LWPZoom Lebron VIIFootball SoccoerTiempo Legend IVNike MERCURIALNike Trail Blazer
By Nike Air Max Shoes on
4/23/2012 4:16 PM
|
http://www.polosralphlaurenoutletonlines.us/
Tory Burch Sale Tory Burch Outlet Tory Burch Shoes Tory Burch Bags Tory Burch Flats Tory Burch Heels Tory Burch Flip Flops Tory Burch Sandals Tory Burch Boots Tory Burch Wedges Tory Burch HandbagsPolo Ralph Lauren Outlet Ralph Lauren Polo Shirts Ralph Lauren Outlet Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Online Mens Polo Ralph Lauren Men's Ocean Challenge Suits Ralph Lauren Big Pony Polo Ralph Lauren City Polo Ralph Lauren Flag Polo Ralph Lauren Hoodies Ralph Lauren Jackets Ralph Lauren Long Sleeved Ralph Lauren Match Polo Ralph lauren Mens Black Watch Ralph lauren Mens Pony Polo Ralph Lauren Shirts ralph lauren sport shorts Ralph Lauren Stripe Polo Ralph Lauren Sweaters Ralph Lauren Tees Ralph Lauren U.S. Polo Ralph Lauren US Open Tennis WOMEN Polo Ralph Lauren Ralph Lauren Big Pony Polo Ralph Lauren Bikini Ralph Lauren City Polo Ralph Lauren Dresses Ralph Lauren Hoodies Ralph Lauren Jackets Ralph Lauren Long Sleeved Ralph Lauren Match Polo Ralph Lauren Shirts Ralph Lauren U.S. Polo Ralph Lauren Women Tee Womens Pony Polo ACCESSORIES Ralph Lauren Handbags Ralph Lauren Hats Ralph Lauren Scarves Ralph Lauren Shoes Lacoste&Hackett Hackett Men's Polo Shirts Hackett Men's Sweatshirts Hackett Mens Long Sleeve Polo Lacoste Men Tees Lacoste Men's Polo Shirts Lacoste Mens Jacket & Outerwear Lacoste Mens Sweat Lacoste Women's Polo Shirts CHILDRENs Polo Ralph Lauren Children Hoodies Children Short Sleeved Polos Wholesale Wholesale men Wholesale women
By Tory Burch Sale on
4/24/2012 10:51 AM
|
Re: BHP's Gift to Low/Non Tax Paying Investors
The numberbirkenstock of straps varies birkenstock pas cherfrom style to style and they also now have straps to secure the foot in the birkenstock hommeback to prevent slippage. There chaussures birkenstockare also three differentbirkenstock paris types of clearance" support birkenstock naturlichsystems now - professional,sandales birkenstock high arch, and soft bed. soldes birkenstockThese help differentbirkenstock soldes wearers with their specific arch concerns andbirkenstock soldes should be tried on before they are bought.
By birkenstock on
4/27/2012 3:00 PM
|